Sea Witch Menu (2025 Update)
Introducing "Sea Witch," a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 703 5th Ave. This vibrant eatery boasts a menu that beautifully harmonizes eclectic flavors with a nautical vibe. The standout dishes include the Pork Schnitzel Sandwich, featuring horseradish mustard and fresh toppings, and the mouthwatering Sea Witch Burger, crafted from a specially blended house ground, which is a must-try for burger enthusiasts. For those seeking a kick, the Sriracha Honey Chicken Sandwich delivers a delightful spicy crunch.
Guests rave about the atmosphere, complete with a mesmerizing fish tank and cozy outdoor space, making it an ideal spot for casual dining. The dedicated staff and creative drink offerings only enhance the experience, making Sea Witch feel like a magical retreat. Whether you're in for the late-night menu or a refreshing draft beer, this spot promises a memorable culinary adventure.
Food
SEA WITCH BURGER
freshly ground 3-way house blend, cooked medium w/ lettuce, chopped onion, tomato, and ketchup (optional American cheese, no extra charge)
GRILLED VEGGIE BURGER
lemony avocado hummus, pickled onions, tamarind sauce, lettuce, and tomato on Martin's potato bun
SRIRACHA HONEY CHICKEN SANDWICH
marinated and breaded, deep fried w/ lettuce and pickle (spicy!)
PORK SCHNITZEL SANDWICH
w/ horseradish mustard, lettuce, onion, and banana peppers on Martin's potato bun
JUBILAT WEDDING KIELBASA SANDWICH
seared smoked garlic kielbasa on Caputo's bread w/ sauerkraut, onion, and house mustard
FILET O' FISH SANDWICH
fresh pollock filet breaded and deep fried, served w/ house tartar sauce and lettuce on a soft roll
OYSTER PO'BOY
cornmeal-fried bluepoints on fresh Caputo's bread, dressed w/ sliced tomato, pickle, shredded red cabbage, and remoulade sauce
SHRIMP PO'BOY
hollowed out Italian bread stuffed with shrimp smothered in a rich butter garlic sauce w/ parsley and scallions
FISH TACOS
lightly fried fresh pollock filet on flour tortillas w/ house made salsa verde, crema, cabbage, scallions, and cilantro
PORK TACOS
seasoned deep fried pork served on flour tortillas w/ a pineapple arbol chile salsa, cabbage, scallions, and cilantro
BLT
applewood smoked bacon, beefsteak tomatoes, lettuce, and mayo
GRILLED CHEESE
American or Havarti
SHISHITO PEPPERS
pan-seared and tossed w/ kosher salt (add garlic, no charge)
CUCUMBER TOMATO SALAD
Persian cucumber, beefsteak tomatoes, w/ a sesame ginger scallion vinaigrette
POPCORN SHRIMP
cornmeal-fried w/ old bay seasoning
CHICKEN NUGGETS
white meat, breaded and fried w/ honey mustard sauce
GRILLED KIELBASA BITES
served w/ horseradish mustard
FRIES
handcut russet potatoes